The first time I tried to soundproof a shared wall was in2021 in a San Francisco mid rise where my neighbor's television was so loud at night that I could follow the dialogue through the wall at normal volume. I walked into a soundproofing supply shop and asked for the best product, and the salesperson handed me a roll of mass loaded vinyl mat that was roughly half an inch thick. He said it would block almost all airborne sound from the neighbor's unit. I brought it home, glued it to the shared wall over a weekend, and waited to hear the difference. The result was that I could still hear the television. Not as clearly as before, but clearly enough to follow what was being said, which meant the mat I bought was not the right mat for the job. Over the next three years I tested six different soundproofing mats on three different shared walls across three different apartments, and three of them failed in ways the product listings did not warn me about. The other three worked but only under specific conditions that I had to learn by trial and error. Here is the six mats I tested, the three that failed and why, the three that worked and what made them work, the install SOP I now use for any shared wall, and the four mistakes I made along the way that cost me either deposit money or wasted weekends.
The Three Soundproofing Mats That Failed in My Tests and What Went Wrong
Out of the six soundproofing mats I tested across three shared walls, three failed in ways that were either my mistake or the product's limitation, and each failure taught me something specific that I now apply to every shared wall soundproofing decision. Here is what failed and what went wrong.
Failure one, half inch mass loaded vinyl glued directly to painted drywall. The mat was the right product class but the wrong thickness for the wall. A shared wall in a wood frame apartment building with single layer drywall on each side needs a minimum of one pound per square foot of mass to block airborne sound meaningfully. Half inch MLV is about half a pound per square foot, which means it adds mass but not enough mass to block the frequencies that carry human voices. The result was that high frequencies were reduced but mid frequencies (the frequencies of human speech) were barely affected. I could still hear the television clearly. The fix is one inch MLV at a minimum, or two layers of half inch MLV with offset seams. Anything less and the mat is decorative rather than functional.
Failure two, foam mat sold as soundproofing on Amazon. The product listing called it "acoustic foam mat for soundproofing walls," which was technically accurate but functionally misleading. Acoustic foam absorbs echo inside a room, it does not block sound from passing through a wall. The mat was soft, easy to install, and completely ineffective for my neighbor's television noise. The mat also left black adhesive residue on the wall that took me two hours to remove at move out. The lesson is that any foam mat sold as soundproofing is almost certainly echo foam, not sound blocking foam. They are different products with different physics, and the labels are confusingly similar.
Failure three, peel and stick MLV mat from a discount retailer. The price was about40 percent cheaper than the name brand MLV I had used before, and I assumed the only difference was the brand. The actual difference was the adhesive backing. The discount mat's adhesive failed within six months and the panels started peeling away from the wall in the corners. By month nine, half the mat was hanging loose and I had to take it all down. The lesson is that the adhesive backing on MLV is what makes or breaks the install, and cheap adhesive fails in renter applications where the wall texture and humidity work against the bond. Spend the extra on name brand adhesive or use a separate construction adhesive that you apply yourself.
The Three Soundproofing Mats That Worked and the Specific Conditions That Made Them Work
The other three soundproofing mats I tested actually worked, but each one worked only under specific conditions that I had to learn by trying the wrong product first. Here is what worked, what conditions made each one work, and what each one cost.
Worked one, one inch mass loaded vinyl on the shared wall. The mat I should have bought the first time. One inch MLV adds roughly one and a half pounds per square foot of mass to the wall, which is enough to block mid frequencies including the frequencies of human voices and most television audio. The install took me about four hours for a12 by9 foot shared wall, including measuring, cutting the mat to size with a utility knife, and mounting it to the wall with construction adhesive. The mat reduced the television noise from clearly intelligible to a muffled sound at normal volume. The mat was noticeable at move out and required about30 minutes of adhesive removal, but the landlord did not charge me for the wall because the surface was clean after removal. Total cost was about $300 for the mat and $20 for the adhesive.
Worked two, two layers of half inch MLV with offset seams. The same half inch mat that failed as a single layer worked when I added a second layer with the seams offset from the first layer. The offset is what blocks the sound leaks that would otherwise pass through the seams between panels. The install took twice as long as a single layer and the cost was roughly double, but the noise reduction was noticeably better than the single layer one inch mat. Two layers of half inch MLV with offset seams is the right approach for shared walls where the neighbor's noise is loud enough that single layer mat is not enough.
Worked three, MLV mat plus a separate layer of drywall over the top. The most effective install I did, and the one I now recommend for shared walls where the neighbor's noise is extreme. The install is essentially adding a second layer of drywall with MLV in between, which is the same construction as a soundproofed wall in new construction. The catch is that this approach is not renter friendly because adding drywall to an existing wall is a permanent modification that requires landlord approval and significant patching at move out. I did this install in a rental where I had landlord approval and a long term lease, and the noise reduction was the best of any approach I tried.
How I Install MLV Mat on a Shared Wall Without Damaging the Existing Paint
The install SOP I now use for any shared wall in a rental is a six step process that takes about four hours for a typical12 by9 foot wall and leaves the wall in good shape at move out. Here is the SOP with the specific products and tools I use.
Step one, measure and cut the mat. Measure the shared wall carefully, accounting for any electrical outlets, light switches, or vent covers that need to be cut around. Cut the mat to size with a sharp utility knife, scoring the mat on one side and then snapping it along the score line. MLV cuts cleanly with a fresh blade but raggedly with a dull blade, so replace the blade before you start. Cut each panel about a quarter inch shorter than the measured dimension to leave room for the mat to expand slightly in the wall.
Step two, prepare the wall. Wipe the wall with a damp microfiber cloth to remove any dust or grease. Tape off the adjacent walls and the floor with painter's tape to keep adhesive off the surfaces you do not want to mark. If the wall has any peeling paint or loose sections, sand them down or fill them with spackle before you start. A clean flat wall is what makes the adhesive bond correctly.
Step three, apply construction adhesive to the wall. Use a high tack construction adhesive designed for use with mass loaded vinyl. Apply the adhesive in a serpentine pattern across the wall section where the mat will mount, covering about60 percent of the surface. Do not apply adhesive to the mat itself, only to the wall. The wall mounted adhesive is what gives you the bond without putting adhesive on the front face of the mat.
Step four, mount the mat. Press the mat firmly against the adhesive within the open time of the adhesive (usually10 to 15 minutes depending on the product). Use a roller or a flat board to press the mat evenly across the wall, working from the center out to the edges to push out any air bubbles. The mat should bond within minutes and reach full bond within 24 hours.
Step five, seal the seams. Seal the seams between panels with a foil tape designed for MLV. The seams are the largest single source of sound leaks, and the foil tape is what blocks the leaks. Press the tape firmly along each seam and overlap the tape at the corners. Do not skip this step. Seams are the difference between a mat install that works and one that leaks sound through every joint.
Step six, seal the edges. Seal the perimeter of the mat where it meets the adjacent walls, the floor, and the ceiling with acoustic caulk. The edges are the second largest source of sound leaks after the seams. The acoustic caulk is paintable and removable, which means it does not damage the surrounding surfaces at move out.
The Four Mistakes I Made That Cost Me Deposit Money or Wasted Weekends
Across the three shared wall installs and six mats tested, I made four specific mistakes that either cost me deposit money at move out or cost me a wasted weekend of work I had to redo. Each mistake is a thing I now watch for in any shared wall soundproofing project.
Mistake one, buying half inch MLV when I needed one inch. The first mat I bought was half inch MLV because it was cheaper and the salesperson said it would work. It did not work. The cost was about $150 for the mat and four hours of install time, plus another four hours taking it down and another $300 buying and installing the one inch replacement. The lesson is that the cheapest mat that meets the minimum specification is not always the right mat. Spend the extra $100 to $200 on the right thickness the first time.
Mistake two, trusting the peel and stick adhesive on a discount mat. The discount mat's adhesive failed within six months and I had to take it all down at move out. The removal took about two hours and the landlord charged me $50 for the adhesive residue that did not come off with soap and water. The lesson is that the adhesive is half the product. If the mat is cheap, the adhesive is probably cheap. Use a name brand mat or apply your own adhesive.
Mistake three, skipping the seam sealing step. In my second install I skipped the foil tape on the seams because I thought the mat panels would be tight enough on their own. The seams leaked sound noticeably and the install underperformed by roughly 20 percent compared to my expectations. I had to take down the mat, apply foil tape to every seam, and remount. The cost was a wasted Saturday. The lesson is that the seams are where sound leaks through, and the foil tape is what closes the leaks. Do not skip the seam sealing.
Mistake four, mounting the mat over an electrical outlet without cutting around it. In my first install I mounted the mat over an electrical outlet because I did not want to deal with cutting around it. The mat covered the outlet and made the outlet inaccessible, which meant I had to take the mat down at move out and patch the wall around the outlet. The lesson is to always cut the mat around electrical outlets, light switches, and vent covers, and to use a single gang electrical box extender to bring the outlet forward to the new wall surface.
What My Three Apartments Sound Like Now and Which Mat I Would Pick Today
Three apartments and three shared wall soundproofing installs later, here is what worked and what I would do differently if I was starting over. The San Francisco mid rise with the one inch MLV mat was the best $300 I ever spent on a shared wall. The neighbor's television went from clearly intelligible to a muffled sound, and the mat stayed up for the full two year lease with no signs of peeling or sagging. The Berkeley apartment with two layers of half inch MLV was the second best install at $600 total, and the noise reduction was better than the single layer mat but the install took twice as long. The Oakland loft where I added drywall over the MLV was the best noise reduction of any install I did, but it required landlord approval and significant work at move out to restore the wall.
If you are about to face the shared wall soundproofing decision for the first time, the lesson from the three apartments is this. Start with one inch MLV on the shared wall with construction adhesive, foil taped seams, and acoustic caulk edges. This is the right answer for most shared walls in most multi story apartments. Add a second layer of half inch MLV if the single layer is not enough. Add drywall over the MLV only if you have landlord approval and a long term lease. Avoid foam mats, peel and stick discount mats, and half inch MLV as a single layer, all of which I tried and regretted. The total cost for a typical12 by9 foot shared wall is $300 to $600 depending on the number of layers, and the install is a single weekend project that any renter can complete with basic tools. The noise reduction is enough to make a shared wall feel like a private wall, and the deposit deduction when you move out is small enough that the math works out in your favor.
Why I Now Recommend Soundproofing Mat First for Any Shared Wall Problem
The reason I recommend soundproofing mat first for any shared wall problem is that the mat is the only soundproofing product that addresses the actual problem (airborne sound passing through the shared wall) without requiring permanent modification to the wall. Ceiling baffles are the right answer for upstairs noise, but they do nothing for side wall noise. Acoustic felt is the right answer for echo inside a room, but it does not block sound passing through a wall. Mass loaded vinyl mat on the shared wall is the only product that directly addresses the shared wall problem while remaining renter friendly.
The secondary reason is that the mat is the most cost effective shared wall soundproofing product per decibel of reduction. The $300 to $600 cost for a typical shared wall is roughly the same as a set of acoustic felt panels, but the noise reduction is significantly higher because the mat blocks the sound at the wall rather than absorbing it after it has entered the room. For renters who want the highest return on investment for shared wall soundproofing, MLV mat is the answer. The install takes a single weekend, the deposit deduction at move out is small, and the noise reduction is enough to make the apartment feel like a private space. The combination of source targeting and renter friendliness is what makes soundproofing mat the second recommendation in my soundproofing cluster after ceiling baffles, and what makes it the product I keep recommending to friends who move into apartments with thin shared walls and loud neighbors.
Discussion (0)
Sign in to join the discussion